News

97% of respondents unable to avail of Retro-Fitting Scheme

This week, Savills Property Agents have released findings of their BER (Building Energy Rating) awareness survey which revealed that 1 in 3 people cannot afford to retrofit their homes. As we are still conducting our own survey which will inform our pre-budget submission for 2024, we thought we would share some of our own findings on the subject so far.

We asked our own members if they have been able to avail of the Retro-Fitting Scheme with less than 3% confirming that they had successfully availed of the scheme. Out of the other 97% of respondents, 57% of people could not avail of the scheme with 40% admitting that they could not afford the scheme as the other associated costs were much too high.

When asked if members believed that the Government backed loan would help older people with retro-fitting, almost 67% answered “no”. The 33% that answered “yes” include the very small number of people who have availed of the scheme as well of those who have not yet applied or looked into the particulars of the scheme.

Only 9% of respondents have said that they plan to apply for the Government backed loan with almost 35% explaining that there is no point in applying as they cannot afford the extra costs. 

Accessible image showcasing senior citizens' participation in Parliament.

With the full cost of a retrofit topping almost €80,000, the requirement to raise a minimum of half of that is proving too difficult for older people during an already arduous cost-of-living crisis. Under the Government’s €8 Billion National Retrofit Plan, 500,000 homes are aimed to be retrofitted and reach a Building Energy Rating of B2 by 2030. This is expected to be aided by a combination of SEAI grants, savings and various types of loans from banks, credit unions and building societies. However, we already know the difficulty facing older adults in acquiring a loan due to their age. That, coupled with a low-rate pension and increasing cost of living, how are older adults expected to produce the funds when their income cannot even support everyday essentials. We have heard from members who have had to give up socialising, TV and phone subscriptions, supporting a cause and even fresh nutritional meals.

We first ask Government to look at how they can financially support older adults in a more sustainable and fair way. However, there is a huge need to change their approach to the Retrofitting Scheme and look at how they can affordably upgrade the homes of older adults, people on lower incomes or those living in social housing.

If you would like to take part in our survey and lend your voice to our pre-budget submission, please follow the link HERE.

The loss is immeasurable, but so is the love left behind

It is with regret that we learned of the passing of two of our founding members last week, Tommy Baldwin and Michael O’Halloran. Both Tommy and Michael were instrumental in setting up the ISCP in 1994-1997 when there were very few organisations working as advocates for the rights of older people.

Michael was also the first CEO of the ISCP and worked determinedly in the early days to develop the profile and awareness of the work of the organisation. Sean Kinsella, a long-time member who worked with Michael in the early years, recalls his innate sense of social justice and his keen interest in education and ensuring that everyone, including older people, had access to it. 

Tommy, who worked tirelessly to grow the organisation and set up the Cork branch as well as the Retired Workers Network will be sadly missed. Nora from the Cork branch who worked alongside Tommy recounts his strong belief in people and speaks of his kindness, patience and unstinting commitment to any work he undertook.  She describes him as ‘A true gentleman’ who was also a keen activist.

Irish senior citizens engaging in advocacy and community events.
Michael O’Halloran
Photo re Late Thomas Tommy Baldwin May 23
Thomas (Tommy) Baldwin

We believe that it is this work in the early days that created the organisation we have today and we thank both Michael and Tommy for the strong legacy they have left behind.

We offer our sincere condolences to the families of both Tommy and Michael. 

The loss is immeasurable but so is the love left behind

Continuing to lobby for a Commissioner for Ageing and Older People

CEO Sue Shaw along with members of the Alliance of Age Sector NGOs, met with TDs and Senators in Leinster House for a second time, on Wednesday 3rd May.

The meeting took place in the AV Room in a bid to garner further cross-party support from TDs and Senators. After a brief introduction and presentation to ‘set the scene’ by Sue Shaw and Maureen Kavanagh (Active Retirement Ireland), the discussion continued for over an hour. The contributions from TDs and Senators alike, were both informative and encouraging and the proposal was well-supported overall. 

CEO Sue Shaw with members of the Age Alliance, TDs and Senators

The general consensus was that the call for a Commissioner was ‘a reasonable ask’ and would be a campaign that could benefit from cross-party support. The collaboration work by the Age Alliance was also noted and very welcomed. It is with great hope that over the coming period, these discussions will progress to a Dail debate on the issue and a similar debate in the Seanad.

We fully appreciated the time and energy shown by the TDs and Senators who attended and we look forward to moving this key action forward.

Ageing in Ireland, too risky?

Over the last few days, Joe Biden has been described as ‘geriatric’, ‘elderly’ and a ‘doddery grandfather’. Multiple papers have ruthlessly taken aim at the American President simply because of his age which the ISCP wholly condemn. Some papers are poking fun at his need for prompt notes at speaking engagements. Which leaves us wondering why it’s not an issue for other state leaders (of varying ages) whom always appear to use prompts. The questions people should be asking are “is he an effective leader?”, “has he brought about significant or positive change?” or “has he kept his campaign promises?”.  It is these criteria by which Presidents should be judged and not in any way related to age.

One radio show produced a segment on Ageism & Working in Your 80’s, which made specific reference to the idea that Biden should be “put in an old folks’ home”. As we are used to working closely with older people, we were not at all surprised to hear from people in their 80s phoning in to defend themselves and each other. The callers each described their active lifestyles, how involved they are in their communities and their full time/part- time employment without feeling any ‘barrier’ that may be associated with their age. In fact, the barriers only became evident when trying to access things such as loans, insurance, housing etc.

Society’s attitude to aging has been contaminated by both public and private institutions who inject an age cap within policies, procedures and eligibility criteria. Many of the inequalities faced by our members were expertly expressed by these callers whom largely made reference to their inability to acquire a loan as they were not deemed “an acceptable risk”. One man in particular wanted to downsize his home as was recommended by the Government in order to free up space for larger families. However, he couldn’t obtain the loan he needed to follow the Government’s advice despite offering security for the loan!

This week in particular, we are hearing of countless stories of older people either being refused travel or car insurance or being offered extortionate quotes due to “risk factors” associated with their age. Our staff member Niamh Kavanagh highlighted this issue, alongside committee member Pat Fitzgerald, during a discussion panel in DCU as part of Global Intergenerational Week. She argued that “Insurance and lending are based on risks factors and likelihood, but the likelihood is; anything could happen to anyone at any given time and at any age. So, we need to look at situations based on broader criteria other than simply being over 70 or 80 years of age.”

Senior Irish Citizens at Parliament event.
Meeting of senior citizens in a classroom discussion.

With regard to Insurance, we must remember that in 2012, the European Court of Justice ruled that it was discriminatory and illegal to price car insurance based on gender, yet there are no such restrictions in place when it comes to age. With our older population increasing, Ireland already lacks any clear cross-departmental strategies for providing a fair and sustainable life for older people. We need to determine just how institutionalised ageism is, and begin to seriously address this issue.

Inclusive event advocating for older adults in Ireland. Focus on senior citizens' rights and community engagement.
Source: © Central Statistics Office, Ireland 2023 https://data.cso.ie/table/PEC16