News
UPDATE AND CURRENT STATUS OF THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS PROVISIONS IN RESPECT OF PENSION ENTITLEMENTS OF RETIRED WORKERS BILL 2021 (THE BILL)

Firstly, the ISCP would like to thank all of our members and member organisations for your ongoing support for this element of our work. We would not have made it to this stage without your support for our email campaign, your engagement with your local TD’s and your support of our awareness demonstrations outside the DAIL.
It is and will continue to be an ongoing piece of work. Legislation is rarely a speedy process. The reasons for this are varied but the lack of support from the Government main parties is a key component in relation to this Bill. An additional cause for delay is the ongoing conflict relating to ‘Speaking Time’. This has delayed the formation of Committees who are charged with working on various topics and policy issues. One of those being the Committee that deals with this proposed Bill.
GIVE RETIRED WORKERS A VOICE
As you are aware, retired workers have endured over a decade of attacks on their pensions, and all are facing further attacks on the very idea of a decent pension when they retire. We believe that pensions are deferred wages, hard won by a long struggle of workers and their trade unions in many cases. But, deals between companies and trade unions can result in significant and long-lasting changes to retired workers pension entitlements. The cumulative effect of this has resulted in a loss of pension income for many retired workers. In some cases, this has led to pension poverty.
The Industrial Relations Provisions in Respect of Pension Entitlements of Retired Workers Bill 2021 (THE BILL) gives a voice to retired workers over what happens to their occupational pension schemes after they have left their employment.
The ISCP has no political affinity to any individual party, however we have a commitment to support our members to have their voice heard by their local and national politicians.
WORK TO DATE:
2021 The proposed Bill (Private members’ Bill proposed by Brid Smith PBP) had wide support within the DAIL and was deferred by the Government for a year to allow for a consultation process to be undertaken.
2022 Submission to consultation process on proposed Bill
Bill passed its second reading in Dáil Eireann on 30th June, 2022.
2023 Bill sent for scrutiny in the first quarter of 2023 as agreed by the Committee on Enterprise Trade and Employment.
Bill passed scrutiny.
Over the period 2021 to date:
Meetings with Minister Damien English, Minister Coveney and Neale Richmond. (awaiting date for meeting with current Minster Peter Burke)
Presentation to TD’s & Senators in AV Room in the Dail
Campaign to move Bill to second stage: Letter, email and in person meetings with TD’s
Awareness gatherings outside the DAIL.
Meeting with individual TD’s & Senators of the Joint Committee responsible for scrutiny of Bill
Prestation to Joint Committee on the need for Bill and to support the Bill’s progression to 3rd Stage
Meeting with Minister Neale Richmond on Bill on response to Questions in the DAIL on the Bill
2024 passed to third stage.
Your representatives from the various organisation within the ISCP have addressed the concerns raised by all Ministers with knowledge, skill and expertise particularly relating to concerns on Industrial Relations issues. The spoke with experience to the current ‘ineffective’ systems in place to address the right of retired workers to have their voice heard.
Note on Bill stages:
There are five stages for all BILLS before the DAIL. This Bill is at 3rd Stage (See 5 stages of Bill at end of this document.)
All Bills that did not complete the legislative process in the Houses of the Oireachtas are deemed to have lapsed, when the 33rd DAIL dissolved In November.
Bills that have lapsed may be reinstated when the new Government is formed. A resolution must be passed in Dáil Éireann for each Bill to restore it to the Order Paper. Bills that are restored to the Order Paper commence at the stage they had reached before the dissolution. The restoration of lapsed Bills to the Order Paper only deals with Bills that have already been published and started the legislative process in the Houses of the Oireachtas. This Bill has been published and has started the legislative process. Bill was passed to Stage 3 before the last Government was dissolved.
Current Status: Awaiting recall of all lapsed Bills before the Dail. Awaiting appointment of all relevant DAIL committees.
This process has been slow due to the ongoing issue over ‘Speaking Time’ in the DAIL.
All parties have been asked to have ready the list of Bills they are requesting for reinstatement. PBP have this Bill at the top of their list. It is they who proposed this Bill through a Private Members Bill by Brid Smith supported by all PBP TD’s. they can now progress it once the Bill is reinstated.
RETIRED WORKERS NOT RETIRED VOTERs
PLEASE CALL ON YOUR TD SUPPORT THE REINSTSTAMENT OF THIS BILL.
WE NEED YOU TO TALK TO YOUR TDS TO ENSURE THIS BILL IS REINSTATED AND PASSED. ASK FOR THEIR SUPPORT TO
- CALL FOR THE REINSTATEMENT OF BILLS
- THEN TO VOTE FOR THIS BILL TO BE REINSTATED ONCE CALLED.
THIS IS CRUCIAL IF WE ARE TO SEND A MESSAGE TO THE CURRENT DAIL THAT OUR MEMBERS DO CARE ABOUT THIS BILL AND THE RIGHTS OF RETIRED WORKERS
Please feel free talk to any one of the representatives from the various organisations and he/she will talk you through ways you can help.
Your Reps:
National Federation of Pensioners Associations: John Nugent @ nugentjohn78@gmail.com
ESB Retired Staff Association: Tony Collins @ tonycollins6952@gmail.com Irish Senior Citizens Parliament: Sue Shaw @ 083 8612179 susan@seniors.ie
Retired Aviation Staff Association: Eileen Sweeny@ rasadub@gmail.com/ Paddy Fagan pj.fagan@yahoo.com
RTE Retired Staff Association: Tony O Connor @ tonyjoconnor@gmail.com
————————————————————————
FIVE STAGES OF A BILL
First Stage (This proposed Bill past this stage)
On First Stage the Bill is initiated. There are two methods of initiating a Bill, introduction and presentation.
“Introduction” is the method used to initiate Private Members’ Bills. Government Bills are initiated by way of presentation; this means a Bill can be published without the prior permission of the Houses.
Second Stage ( This proposed Bill past this stage)
On Second Stage, the general principles of the Bill are debated. Second Stage of a Bill is a debate on the motion “That the Bill be now read a Second Time” and provides Members with an opportunity to discuss the general principles of the Bill, what the Bill contains and what might be included in a relevant way.
THE BILL HAS COMPLETED AND PASSED THESE FIRST TWO STAGES
BEFORE THE DAIL WAS DISSOLVED THEY VOTED TO HAVE THE BILL PASS TO THE THIRD STAGE
We Await the Bills office to set the date for reinstatement of Bill at this point and begin the work of the third stage
Third (Committee) Stage
Third Stage, which is also called Committee Stage, involves detailed consideration of the Bill, with separate decisions on each section and each amendment.
Committee Stage is usually taken in a select committee of the Dáil and a committee of the whole Seanad. Some Bills, generally urgent Bills or those affecting a number of Departments, may be examined in a committee of the whole Dáil.
Fourth (Report) Stage
On Fourth Stage, which is also called Report Stage, amendments arising out of or dealing with issues discussed on Committee Stage are considered.
Fifth (Final) Stage
On Fifth Stage, the Bill is passed by the House. It is a relatively short stage when the House reviews and accepts the Bill, and there is usually little general contribution.
When the Bill passes all Stages in one House it is then sent to the other House for the same process to be repeated. The House in which a Bill is initiated is known as the “First House”, with the other House being known as the “Second House”. Where the Second House makes amendments to a Bill, the amendments are returned to the First House for its agreement.
FIVE STAGES OF A BILL
First Stage (PASSED)
On First Stage the Bill is initiated. There are two methods of initiating a Bill, introduction and presentation.
“Introduction” is the method used to initiate Private Members’ Bills. Government Bills are initiated by way of presentation; this means a Bill can be published without the prior permission of the Houses.
Second Stage (PASSED)
On Second Stage, the general principles of the Bill are debated. Second Stage of a Bill is a debate on the motion “That the Bill be now read a Second Time” and provides Members with an opportunity to discuss the general principles of the Bill, what the Bill contains and what might be included in a relevant way.
WE HAVE PASSED THESE FIRST TWO STAGES
BEFORE THE DAIL WAS DISSOLVED THEY VOTED TO HAVE THE BILL PASS TO THE THIRD STAGE
We Await the Bills office to set the date for reinstatement of Bill at this point and begin the work of the third stage
Third (Committee) Stage
Third Stage, which is also called Committee Stage, involves detailed consideration of the Bill, with separate decisions on each section and each amendment.
Committee Stage is usually taken in a select committee of the Dáil and a committee of the whole Seanad. Some Bills, generally urgent Bills or those affecting a number of Departments, may be examined in a committee of the whole Dáil.
Fourth (Report) Stage
On Fourth Stage, which is also called Report Stage, amendments arising out of or dealing with issues discussed on Committee Stage are considered.
Fifth (Final) Stage
On Fifth Stage, the Bill is passed by the House. It is a relatively short stage when the House reviews and accepts the Bill, and there is usually little general contribution.
When the Bill passes all Stages in one House it is then sent to the other House for the same process to be repeated. The House in which a Bill is initiated is known as the “First House”, with the other House being known as the “Second House”. Where the Second House makes amendments to a Bill, the amendments are returned to the First House for its agreement.
INTERNATIONAL WOMEN’S DAY
Demonstrations are planned from Tokyo to Mexico City, to celebrate International Women’s Day, with this year’s theme calling to “Accelerate Action.” This comes at a time where many activists worry that the current political environment may result in a backsliding on many of the rights they’ve long fought for. One in four countries reported a backlash against women’s rights last year, according to U.N. data.
International Women’s Day was first celebrated in the USA in 1909 and internationally in 1911.
While equality for women has come a long way, we still have some key areas outstanding. Political representation is an area that needs to be addressed. In Ireland, of our 160 TD’s only 36 are women, only one in five.
Women still form the largest percentage of those in low paid insecure jobs, they form the majority of people giving care both paid and unpaid. We are all aware of just how inadequate income in this area of work is. Recently, on RTE’s Liveline, we listened to the heart-breaking stories told by people who are still actively caring for a family member but on receipt of their state pension their care’s allowance was cut or stopped.
During the debates in the run up to the last election (November 2024) we heard a lot of discussion on crime and crime on our streets. No doubt, this issue is very important and needs change, however the issue of crime within the home was rarely mentioned. Domestic violence within the home is as much a crime, accounting for more deaths than those though gangland killings. The Gardai receives between 500- 600 calls per week relating to domestic and sexual violence within the home.
All to often women still have no where to go, if they leave the family home due to violence. A housing crisis and with only one third of the required refuges to accommodate women and their children mean that many women stay in unsafe and violent homes.
Yesterday in Nerja, Spain I spoke to a group of older people calling for equal rights for women and I asked what prompted them to engage with this issue. “ Very simple” they said “ women still have not got access to full equality”

The theme ‘accelerate action’ requires us all to examine how we support equality for women and where we can take action or offer support on a practical level.
Convention on the Rights of Older People

The Irish Senior Citizens Parliament supports the call from a range of NGO’s across Europe calling for a Convention on the Rights of Older People
Older persons are often forgotten and left behind, but they have much to contribute to our societies, and it is crucial to promote a wider understanding of their role in order to build a society for all ages. (Rosa Kornfeld-Matte UN Independent Expert on the enjoyment of all human rights by older persons)
Europe is experiencing a significant demographic shift as its population ages rapidly. The proportion of individuals aged 65 and over is on the rise, and this trend is expected to continue in the foreseeable future. This shift prompts us to consider how older individuals exercise their rights within contemporary society and presents new challenges that our communities must be prepared to address.
Population ageing is one of the most profound transformations of our time. For the first time in history, the global population is projected to have fewer children than older individuals. Currently, approximately 700 million people, or 10 percent of the world’s population, are over the age of 60. Projections indicate that by 2050, the number of older individuals will double, reaching 20 percent of the global population. This reality underscores the necessity of enabling older persons to remain integrated into society and actively participate in the formulation and implementation of policies that impact their lives and well-being.
Speaking at the launch of the Handbook of Rights for Older people Marjan Sedmak (AGE Platform Europe President) said Maintaining and enhancing our basic European values of respect, solidarity and equality should remain the main priority guiding all EU external and internal actions. Respect and enjoyment of ones’ human rights by all individuals is a fundamental feature of our democratic societies. The right to be respected and treated with dignity, to take part and be included in society may look fairly natural to some people, but can be a real challenge for some parts of our ageing population. And this is all the more true in these tough economic times, when fundamental rights tend to be overshadowed by economic concerns.
Human rights are entitlements and freedoms of all human beings, whatever our nationality, place of residence, sex, age, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, language, or any other status. Human rights are held by all persons equally and universally. They are based on core principles like dignity, fairness, equality, respect and autonomy. Human rights are present in our day-to-day lives and protect our freedom to control the different aspects of our own lives. (HANDBOOK HUMAN RIGHTS AGE PLATFORM)
Human rights are enshrined and protected by law, encompassing international treaties as well as national constitutions and legislation. The first global acknowledgment that all human beings possess inherent rights was established following World War II with the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) by the United Nations in 1948.
Following the adoption of the UDHR, numerous countries have ratified various human rights treaties, which outline the obligations of governments to act in specific ways or to refrain from certain actions in order to promote and protect the human rights and fundamental freedoms of their citizens. Collectively, these treaties form what is known as international human rights law.
By accepting the provisions of these treaties, states incur legal responsibilities to ensure that all individuals within their borders can enjoy these rights and to provide remedies in cases of violations. International human rights law establishes clear obligations for governments, holding them accountable to the international community and providing mechanisms for measures and sanctions against any state that fails to meet these commitments.
Older individuals are often overlooked within the existing international legal framework. Currently, there are no universally applicable international standards that can guide the development of legislation aimed at protecting the rights of this demographic. Consequently, the present international legal framework is fragmented and lacks the comprehensiveness needed to effectively address the specific protection gaps that hinder older persons from fully enjoying their human rights.
A single instrument is needed to amalgamate the principles of older person’s rights into one convention. (HelpAge Briefing Paper)
A Report of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights states
(Summary document of the multi-stakeholder meeting on the human rights of older persons)
- States should, in collaboration with civil society, national human rights institutions, the United Nations and older persons themselves, develop and adopt a comprehensive convention on the human rights of older persons that builds on existing rights and regional instruments.
This convention seeks to enhance the quality of life for older adults. Similar to previous U.N. conventions addressing the rights of women, children, and persons with disabilities, it is expected to positively impact the targeted population. Specific initiatives may include economic empowerment through the establishment of rights to an adequate standard of living, work, education, and access to health and long-term care services.
Furthermore, the convention will define the responsibilities of ratifying member states with respect to older adults and will strengthen existing laws with clear and precise language. It will mandate rights to accessibility, information, and judicial protection.
In addition, it will enshrine the right to healthcare, mental health services, essential medications, and social services for older individuals.
The convention will promote dignity by safeguarding the right to privacy, freedom from abuse and violence, and physical security. It will also ensure that subgroups, including LGBTQ+ elders, older adults with disabilities, and Indigenous elders, are included and guaranteed the same rights.
Finally, the convention will provide policymakers with a comprehensive framework for developing effective policies concerning older adults, encourage data collection on elder populations, and assist governments in resource allocation. Ultimately, it aims to inspire and justify additional programs that enhance quality of life as individuals age.
ISCP know that the Convention on Rights for Older People is not a panacea for all discrimination, however it is a forceful step in the right direction.